Is it worth repairing or replacing the engine on a 2009 Subaru Legacy/outback?

As a general rule of thumb, an engine replacement on a 2009 Subaru Legacy/outback (compact suv segment, vehicle value roughly $3,000–$3,500) is usually worth it when the installed cost stays under about $1,500 — roughly 50% of what the vehicle is worth.

2009 Subaru Legacy/outback Engines

Used and remanufactured engines that fit the 2009 Subaru Legacy/outback. Each unit below is matched to this vehicle, warranty-backed, and shipped with freight quoted at checkout from Peak Powertrain.

Available Engines (2)

Used Engine
Price
$2,704.00
Engine:
2.5L
Mileage:
126,263
Condition:
used
Used Engine
Price
$2,704.00
Engine:
2.5L
Mileage:
108,101
Condition:
used

Other Subaru Legacy/outback Years

2025(1)
2022(14)
2021(18)
2020(18)
2019(10)
2018(21)
2017(67)
2016(4)
2015(2)
2013(2)
2012(3)
2011(3)
2010(4)
2009(2)
2008

2009 Subaru Legacy/outback Engines

Available Engines (2)

Used Engine

Used Engine

Other Subaru Legacy/outback Years

2009 Subaru Legacy/outback Engine Market Context

Is replacing the engine worth it?

Frequently Asked Questions