Is it worth repairing or replacing the engine on a 2009 Subaru Forester?

As a general rule of thumb, an engine replacement on a 2009 Subaru Forester (mid-size sedan segment, vehicle value roughly $2,500–$3,000) is usually worth it when the installed cost stays under about $1,250 — roughly 50% of what the vehicle is worth.

What years of Subaru Forester does an remanufactured or new engine fit?

Based on vendor-verified fitment data across 13 listed engines, remanufactured and new engines for this model cover the 1998–2017 model years. Always confirm your exact VIN or engine/transmission code before ordering, since fitment can vary by submodel or engine.

2009 Subaru Forester Engines

Remanufactured engines that fit the 2009 Subaru Forester. Each unit below is matched to this vehicle, warranty-backed, and shipped with freight quoted at checkout from Peak Powertrain.

Available Engines (3)

SUBARU EJ25E 06-09 ENGINE
Price
$4,280.26
Engine:
2.5L
Condition:
remanufactured
Used Engine
Price
$4,303.00
Engine:
2.5L
Mileage:
134,645
Condition:
used
Used Engine
Price
$1,947.00
Engine:
2.5L
Mileage:
172,305
Condition:
used

Other Subaru Forester Years

2025(27)
2024(19)
2023(29)
2022(16)
2021(40)
2020(33)
2019(44)
2018(122)
2017(83)
2016(78)
2015(109)
2014(99)
2013(22)
2012(34)
2011(32)

2009 Subaru Forester Engines

Available Engines (3)

SUBARU EJ25E 06-09 ENGINE

Used Engine

Used Engine

Other Subaru Forester Years

2009 Subaru Forester Engine Market Context

Is replacing the engine worth it?

Frequently Asked Questions